← Newsletter

Newsletter · Jan 30, 2026

Why trying to prove yourself as a leader will destroy your team

If your LinkedIn feed is anything like mine, half the people you know seem to have started a new job this year. 

Roles at new companies, promotions at the same company. It feels like it is everywhere. This is great news for all of those people, but taking a new job, especially a leadership role, presents challenges. Most new leaders that I work with, including myself, struggle with one common challenge.

They want to prove themselves.

The problem isn’t that they want to prove themselves, it is how they do it. They do it by talking. A lot. 

  • They talk during team meetings. 
  • They talk during 1-on-1s. 
  • They talk before their employees. 
  • They talk over employees.

Sound familiar? Maybe your boss does it. Maybe you do it.

Talking too much isn’t just annoying, it is also problematic for your entire team. This desire to prove yourself is causing at least three problems for your organization.

As you read this, if anything sounds familiar, schedule a call so we can diagnose what’s actually happening.

Problem #1: Your team becomes a collection of order-takers

When managers constantly jump in with solutions instead of asking questions, team members stop thinking for themselves. They wait to be told what to do. They don’t offer ideas in meetings. They don’t take initiative when problems arise.

The result? You as the manager become the bottlenecks for every decision. Projects slow down and you can’t get enough done.

Problem #2: You bleed your best talent

The best individual contributors get promoted because they can solve problems. But when those new managers, maybe you, lead by solving every problem themselves, it means they’re doing their team’s job for them.

Team members who could grow into future leaders feel micromanaged and undervalued. They leave which hurts your team and the company.

Problem #3: Your managers (YOU) are heading for burnout

Managers who won’t stop talking can’t stop doing. They take on more and more work themselves because they don’t trust their team (or more accurately, they haven’t learned how to empower their team). This creates a vicious cycle where they have even less time to actually manage, so they just keep doing the work instead.

Eventually they break. And the team they leave behind is less capable than when they started..

Solving this is both easy and hard.

The easy part of the solution, if you are the one causing the problem, is to just change. When I was a new manager, I used to sit in meetings with three words running on repeat in my head.

JUST STOP TALKING, JUST STOP TALKING

I was always looking for an excuse to have someone else say what they think or propose their own solution. That sounds simple, but of course, it is easier said than done. I went a bit deeper into my specific experiences solving this for myself in a recent YouTube video, so if you want to hear a bit more, make sure to take a look.

The harder part is solving this at an organizational level. It involves instilling practices of building trust, setting expectations, and giving feedback for all managers on day 1. At Better Every Day Studios, those are exactly the kinds of programs we focus on building with our clients so if you are responsible for building leaders in your organization, and need help getting your managers to stop talking, set up a time for us to talk.

Have a great new year.

Matt

Get the monthly newsletter

Lessons from conversations with leaders across hard tech, in your inbox once a month.

Subscribe